Complete Story

MAJDIK, Zoltan P. and PLATT, Carrie Anne

Spring 2012, 42:2, pages 120-143

Selling Certainty: Genetic Complexity and Moral Urgency in Myriad Genetics BRACAnalysis Campaign

This essay analyzes Myriad Genetics marketing of the BRACAnalysis genetic test to argue that the campaign creates a unique and problematic understanding of choice- and decision making in the domain of applied genetic biotechnologies. The essay identifies how the campaign creates a subject position that invites audiences into a double bind of action and moral obligation, where specific decisions to make powerful medical choices becomes circumscribed as a necessity. A reduction and oversimplification of technical, scientific complexity replaces deliberative processes and phronetic understandings of complex situations and exigencies with intuition and feeling as warrants for action; in turn, a resultant appearance of empowerment becomes dialectically invested in an invocation of moral urgency and necessity.

Read the Rhetoric Society Quarterly Get information about our conferences Get information about our institutes Learn about becoming a member Access members-only content